COSMETICS · CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE
Cosmetic claims: does your evidence support your promises?
A supplier document about an active ingredient is not automatically proof of the finished product effect. Before printing packaging, link each cosmetic claim to suitable evidence and the actual conditions of use.
Checked on 20 November 2026.
Planning new packaging, an online description or a campaign for a cosmetic product? Review efficacy claims before sending the text for printing or advertising. A common question is whether a supplier catalogue describing ingredient properties is sufficient to promise an effect for a finished cream, serum or shampoo.
Link the claim to the specific product
Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 requires adequate and verifiable support for cosmetic claims. The presentation of an effect must not go beyond the available evidence. Extrapolating ingredient properties to a finished product also needs appropriate substantiation; raw material information is therefore not automatic proof for any formulation.
We recommend recording the full wording and intended meaning of each promise. “Contains ingredient X” and “visibly reduces the appearance of wrinkles” are different claims. For the latter, assess the evidence for the claimed effect, its visibility and the conditions under which it is expected to occur.
Read what the test actually demonstrated
When reviewing a test report, check the product used, method, measured effect and user group. Distinguish instrumental measurements, expert assessments and participant opinions. Presenting a satisfaction questionnaire as a measurement of a physiological effect can create an impression that differs from what the data support.
For an internal review, ask a simple question: would the average consumer understand the wording to mean more than was actually tested? If so, adjust the wording or prepare more suitable evidence. Where necessary, clearly state the method of use and the conditions associated with the effect.
Supplier information is a starting point for assessment
Obtain the full report or sufficiently detailed technical documentation from the supplier, rather than just a promotional slide. Check the concentration and system in which the ingredient was tested. Record which differences between the test and your formulation require further explanation.
The Technical document on cosmetic claims, available through CIRCABC, helps assess examples. It is a non-binding best-practice tool. Its examples do not replace an assessment of all the circumstances of a particular product and message.
Review websites, photographs and translations too
Ireland’s competent authority, HPRA, points out that the rules also cover websites, social media and other advertising material. A product may have an appropriate label, while a sales description later attributes broader effects to it. The review should therefore cover all sales channels.
We recommend a claims register linking each claim to its evidence and approved wording. Include translations and instructions for distributors. When the formulation, method of use or supplier changes, check whether the previous substantiation remains applicable. The review should help colleagues use consistent, documented messaging.
Prepare the documentation before a new campaign
BiSafe helps review cosmetic claims and product documentation. Send the formulation, proposed wording and available evidence to info@bisafe.si. Find out more through our cosmetic product services. A review can identify which statements are supported and where further substantiation is needed.

